Feature Articles

A musical battle: W1-equipped Apple AirPods vs. BeatsX vs. Beats Solo3

By Bryan Chan & Kenny Yeo - 3 Apr 2017

BeatsX

BeatsX

The BeatsX are clearly aimed at a sportier demographic.

The BeatsX are the latest Apple W1-equipped headphones to be released. Clearly designed for more sporty use, they are neckband-style in-ear headphones. Like most other Beats products, the BeatsX are available in a variety of colors. Ours came in black, but there’s also white, gray, and blue.

The BeatsX are packaged neatly and come with just about all the accessories one could ask for. There’s a compact carrying case, three additional ear tips, and even two wingtips for the times when you need a more secure fit. Make sure to try out the tips to get a good fit because that’s crucial to getting the best sound quality. Unlike the Powerbeats3, the BeatsX are not rated to be sweat or water resistant. Even so, taking them for short workouts shouldn’t be too much for a problem.

The neckband itself feels nice on the skin and is comfortable to wear.

For readers new to neckband-style headphones, you wear them by placing the band that connects the two headphones over your neck. This way, when you remove the headphones, they can rest and dangle from your neck. The BeatsX headphones themselves are magnetic, so you can attach them together to form a necklace on your neck. It also helps to keep them tangle-free when you store them away in the carrying case.

The headphones are magnetic and will automatically attach themselves to each other if you leave them on your neck.

Like the AirPods, the BeatsX charge via a Lightning port.

Near the left headphone is an inline remote with three buttons for controlling playback, volume, and activating Siri. Further down the left side and closer to the middle, there’s a housing with a Lightning port that is used for charging. This means you can use your iPhones charging cable to charge the BeatsX. Beats claims a battery life of eight hours for the BeatsX. The headphones also feature Fast Fuel, so a quick 5-minute charge is enough to give the BeatsX 2 hours of playback. A full charge, according to Beats, takes about 45 minutes. Thanks to Fast Fuel and the BeatsX rather decent battery life, the BeatsX never ran out of battery during our use

Since the BeatsX are equipped with Apple’s W1 chip, pairing it with Apple devices was a breeze. Turn it on for the first time near an unlocked iPhone and a pop-up will appear prompting you to pair the BeatsX. Confirm that you the two devices paired and that’s it. And in about a minute or two, you can also see that the BeatsX have been paired with aMacBook Pro and iPad.

The inline remote makes it easy to control music playback, volume, and activate Siri.

The nozzles are slightly angled and offer great noise isolation when used with the silicon tip of the right size.

We suppose you could say that the BeatsX has the typical Beats sound signature. There is ample bass, but we won’t call it overpowering, just overemphasized. Fortunately, the bass is punchy and fairly clean and doesn’t muddy the rest of the sound too much. Mids are slightly recessed and so vocals and strings end up sounding a little distant, but there is also some unevenness here, which results in a harsh and somewhat piercing sound. This is most evident on some female vocals and some percussion instruments. Nevertheless, we found the bass-heavy sound signature to be appropriate for working out as it offers more motivation especially when paired with the right tracks.

At about RM628, the BeatsX are currently the most affordable Apple W1-equipped wireless headphones that you can buy. And if you don’t mind in-ear headphones, the BeatsX is the more value for money option. You do lose some of nifty functions of the AirPods, but as in-ear headphones, the BeatsX provide better sound isolation, and, to usat least, have a better and more full-bodied sound.

BeatsX